INSTRUCTIONAL AND LIBRARY MATERIALS – CHALLENGED
ADMINISTRATIVE PROCEDURE
I. A review committee of at least seven (7) members, consisting of:
(1) Building Principal
(2) Students
(2) Community members (one or more shall be parents)
(2) Staff Members – (1) English Teacher
shall be appointed each year by the superintendent, subject to the approval of
the Board. It shall be the duty of this committee to
review any material, which
has its appropriateness challenged and to complete the review within ten (10)
working days. No selected
materials, whose appropriateness is challenged, shall
be removed from the school, except upon the written recommendation of this
committee with the concurrence of the Principal and Superintendent, or by the
Board when a recommendation of a review committee
is received. Access to
questioned materials can be denied the student, if the parent so desires.
II. In the event a complaint is made, the following procedures will apply:
A. The complaint shall be heard first by the person(s) providing the material in
question.
B. All complaints to staff members regarding any material shall be immediately
reported to the Building Principal involved, whether the
complaint is by
telephone, letter or in personal conversation.
C. The Building Principal, in concord with the teacher involved, shall contact
the complainant to discuss the complaint and attempt to
resolve it informally.
D. If the complaint is not resolved informally, the complainant shall be
supplied with a standard printed form (IJJ-E1/IJL-E1), which
shall be completed
and returned before consideration is given to the complaint.
E. If the Principal does not receive the formal request for consideration within
two (2) weeks, the complaint is considered closed.
F. Upon receipt of a completed IJJ-E1/IJL-E1 form, the Principal will call a
meeting of the review committee to consider the complaint.
III. The committee shall meet to discuss and evaluate the disputed material and
shall prepare a written report on the material containing
their recommendation
or disposition of the matter.
The review committee shall:
A. Examine the challenged material using IJJ-E2/IJL-E2.
B. Determine professional acceptance by reading critical reviews of the
material, if readily available.
C. Weigh values and faults and form opinions based on the material as a whole
rather than on passages and selections taken out of
context.
D. Discuss the challenged resource in the context of the educational program.
E. Extend an invitation to discuss the challenged item with the complainant when
appropriate.
F. Prepare a written report to be submitted to the Superintendent.
The Superintendent/designee shall notify the complainant of the decision. In
answering the complainant, the Superintendent/designee
shall explain how and why
the material was selected, give the guidelines used in selection, and cite
authorities used in reaching
decisions. If the committee decides to retain the
work that prompted the complaint; the complainant shall be given an explanation.
If
the complaint is judged valid, the Superintendent/designee will acknowledge
it and make recommended changes as suggested by the
review committee.
IV. If the complainant is still not satisfied, he/she may appeal to the Board,
through the Superintendent. The Board will make a final
determination of the
issue. The Board may set aside a portion of a regular meeting or call a special
meeting for the purpose of receiving
testimony from representatives of the
various points of view. The material in question shall be:
A. Reviewed objectively and in its full content;
B. Evaluated in terms of the needs and interest of students, school, curriculum
and community;
C. Considered in the light of differing opinions; and
D. Reviewed in light of the criteria for initial selection and purpose as
provided herein.
The Board will announce its decision in writing no later than the conclusion of
the next regular meeting of the Board following its receipt
of said testimony.
BOOKS FOR ORAL OR WRITTEN REPORTS: Each student may be presented with a
list of books for possible reading. If any student chooses a book containing
subject material, which he/she considers improper, he/she should bring the
material to the attention of his/her teacher and should choose a different book
for his/her report.
The teacher shall supply the student with a review form IJJ-E1/IJL-E1when the
student makes the objection.
BOOKS FOR IN-DEPTH CLASS STUDY: If any student or parent has a valid
objection to any book discussed in any classroom, he/she should follow the steps
to have the book reviewed.
The teacher shall supply the student with an alternate book for equal credit.
The above excludes textbooks.
MULTI-MEDIA: Each teacher will assume responsibility for the quality of
any enrichment materials used in his/her classroom.
DATE ADOPTED: JULY 1, 2003